Plans announced by Hind Kabawat to allow Syrian mothers to pass citizenship to their children leave crucial questions unanswered.
In its recently published paper, Children Left Behind, the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Syria called on Damascus to reform legislation governing legal identity and nationality. A day later, on 4 November, Syrian Minister of Social Affairs and Labour Hind Kabawat delivered the opening remarks at a high-level panel discussion on legal identity in Syria.
When Kabawat announced plans to allow Syrian mothers to pass their nationality to children fathered by non-Syrians, she began with the story of Maryam, a woman from Daraa. Her marriage had never been officially registered, her husband had died, and she was struggling to obtain documents for her children. It was a fitting example of why Syria needs to reform its nationality law. But then Kabawat listed the conditions: the marriage must be officially registered, the mother must be Syrian by origin, and the “applicant" must have no criminal convictions. Even if these conditions are met, the application must still be approved by the relevant authorities.
While the proposed reform would be welcome news for Syrian women who meet its conditions, the details outlined so far raise three concerns.
1. The state may require women to provide documentation that the conflict itself made difficult to obtain
A reform that promises Syrian mothers the right to pass on their nationality, only to deny it to those whose marriages were never registered or whose husbands disappeared during the war would be a cruel irony.
Years of conflict have left many Syrian families struggling to obtain the documents needed to establish their legal status. The Assad regime refused to recognise documents issued outside its control, while crossing front lines to reach government registries was dangerous. In opposition-held areas, civil registration services were frequently disrupted. How is one expected to have an officially registered marriage under these conditions? Many Muslim couples therefore relied on informal, or urfi, marriages.
Such marriages can be registered retrospectively, but this requires evidence and witnesses who can confirm that the marriage took place. For families displaced by the war, whose documents have been lost or whose witnesses have died or disappeared, that may be exceedingly difficult. The possibility of retrospective registration offers little reassurance to those who cannot meet its requirements.
2. Children born outside marriage may be excluded from the proposed reform
The marriage-registration requirement also raises questions about children born outside legally recognised marriages, such as through sexual violence. Under existing Syrian law, children born in Syria to Syrian mothers may acquire nationality when their legal relationship to the father has not been established. Yet this protection has historically been difficult to access, particularly because of social stigma and administrative barriers. If the proposed reform requires an officially registered marriage, it remains unclear whether it would offer these children a more accessible route to nationality or reproduce the obstacles they already face. A child’s right to nationality should not depend on whether their parents were married.
3. The reform would preserve unequal rights for Syrian mothers and fathers
Interestingly, under Article 3(a) of Syria's nationality law, children whose Syrian paternity is legally established acquire nationality whether born inside or outside Syria. The provision does not expressly require their parents' marriage to be registered. Although establishing paternal descent may still involve documentation difficulties, the law recognises nationality through the father as a legal entitlement. The proposed maternal pathway, by contrast, would depend on additional eligibility conditions and administrative approval. One such condition is that the mother must be Syrian by origin. Naturalised Syrian women would therefore be excluded from the proposed pathway, despite holding Syrian citizenship. The reform would thus preserve discrimination between mothers and fathers while introducing another distinction between Syrian mothers themselves.
Much remains unclear about the proposed reform. Are mothers without an officially registered marriage automatically excluded? What happens to children conceived through sexual violence with an unknown father? On what grounds could the authorities reject an application, and whose criminal record would be examined? Will the new rules apply to children born before their enactment? Will the proposed reform also apply to children born outside Syria?
The uncertainty extends to the proposal’s status itself: while Kabawat described it as awaiting approval, Syrian officials have given conflicting accounts of how far it has progressed. The government has also announced measures to make civil registration easier, but their details remain unclear. These details will ultimately determine who can actually benefit from the reform.
For women like Maryam, the proposed reform could make little difference unless the government addresses the obstacles that have kept them from obtaining documentation in the first place. Syria has an opportunity to end a longstanding injustice, but that requires more than allowing mothers to apply for rights that fathers already enjoy. The principle should be simple: nationality is a right, not a request.